The way we see Charlie Kirk, his life and death, and indeed, nearly everything, is determined less by the facts than by our personal paradigms. Less by the truth than by our algorithms.
This past week showed me how the media environments we’ve built for ourselves shape our realities. It’s no wonder we’ve become so polarized: we live in different worlds.
My Christian friends and my Republican friends are grieving deeply. The Charlie Kirk they remember was a uniter: someone committed to reaching across the political aisle and engaging those who disagreed with him with great civility. He was a lion of the faith, boldly proclaiming the gospel in an arena where it is rarely heard. He was a loving and committed husband and father who regularly encouraged other young men to follow this highest calling. He was a good Christian man, and now he is a modern-day martyr.
My progressive friends and my atheist friends have, without exception, expressed horror over his murder. They have unequivocally condemned political violence. They’ve shared how much sadness they feel for his wife and little children. But the Charlie Kirk they remember was not any of the things I listed above. He was a man with a long and unapologetic history of spreading his racist and sexist views, one more prominent Christian whose attitudes toward his fellow human beings seemed to be shaped more by Donald Trump than Jesus Christ.
So, who is right?
To some extent, both.
Depending on how you’ve trained your algorithm, you may not have seen Kirk with Bill Maher, a famously strident atheist. He and Charlie had a really interesting, thoughtful discussion about faith vs. skepticism—though Maher was, in his typical fashion, more caustic. The two displayed mutual respect and kindness, and Charlie was completely unruffled by Bill’s occasional inflammatory comments.
Can you see how moments like these elevated Charlie Kirk in the opinions of many people, especially believers?
At his appearance on the Jubilee debate forum, Charlie Kirk faced Dean Withers, a young liberal TikToker with a huge following. Due to the format, their interaction was brief, but completely polite despite the topic: abortion. During their debate, Charlie told Dean he’d made a good point, and when Dean stood to return to his seat, Charlie grinned and shook his hand, telling him he’d been the best debater so far.
Dean Withers wept openly when Charlie Kirk died.
My friends on the left, can you see how moments like these endeared Charlie Kirk to even some of his most dedicated ideological opponents?
At one of his events he was approached by a young person who described themselves as a transgender male who was uncertain about medical interventions, and asked Charlie for his advice. He first asked for more of their story. The advice he gave and the tone in which he gave it might surprise those whose algorithms paint him as a transphobic monster. He advised seeking a diagnosis first, and caution about medical intervention. But what is most striking about the interaction is his kindness, and the apparent care he has toward this young stranger.
Can you see why people whose algorithms show them moments like these believe the man has been unjustly smeared as a bigot?
That is the Charlie Kirk half of America is mourning.
They are, quite understandably, deeply offended by those saying critical things about him. After all, they’ve seen no evidence of any wrongdoing, only of kindness and good-faith debate.
They might be surprised to learn that Joe Biden published a statement on the day Charlie died: “There is no place in our country for this kind of violence. It must end now. Jill and I are praying for Charlie Kirk’s family and loved ones.” They might be more surprised to learn that he released this statement despite the fact that Charlie Kirk publicly called for Joe Biden’s execution. In fact, he called for executions in general to be “quick” and “televised,” and pondered what age would be best for children to begin watching them.
My Christian friends, can you see how these statements have given others a very different picture of Charlie Kirk than the one you’ve seen?
Kirk fully embraced the white nationalist “Great Replacement Theory.” “The great replacement strategy, which is well underway every single day in our southern border, is a strategy to replace white rural America with something different,” he said. “They [Democrats] hate those of you that live in rural and small America…and they have a plan to try and get rid of you.” He compared Democrats to Stalin and warned, “You believe in God, country, family, faith, and freedom, and they won’t stop until you and your children and your children’s children are eliminated.”
Can you see how these accusations do not align with a man who was supposedly a uniter? Can you see how hearing him described as civilly reaching across the political aisle rings hollow to those who’ve heard him talk this way?
Kirk was a vocal opponent of DEI initiatives. His supporters saw this as commonsense advocacy for merit-based hiring. After all, who wants a pilot or surgeon who wasn’t held to the same rigorous standards as their white counterparts? They may not have heard the type of language he used over the years on this topic, though. “If I’m dealing with somebody in customer service who’s a moronic black woman, I wonder is she there because of her excellence, or is she there because of affirmative action?” When speaking about prominent black women such as Michelle Obama and Supreme Court Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson, he said, “…you do not have the brain processing power to otherwise be taken really seriously. You had to go steal a white person’s slot to go be taken somewhat seriously.”
Can you see how comments like these, which are not isolated but part of a long pattern, led an awful lot of people to believe he was a racist?
In 2020, FOX News producer Blake Neff resigned when FOX learned of his “horrendous and deeply offensive” racist posts online. Charlie Kirk didn’t seem to have a problem with the racist posts; he hired him. Neff would go on to help Kirk produce content about how Martin Luther King, Jr. was actually a terrible person and passing the Civil Rights Act was a big mistake.
Do you see how accusations of racism against Kirk are not all baseless smears? Does knowing these things help you see others’ perspectives with more understanding?
He told a 14-year-old girl there is “an argument to bring back the MRS degree,” and to “be clear, that’s why you’re going to college, right? Don’t lie to yourself. Don’t, like, ‘Ah, I’m going, I’m studying sociology.’ No you’re not. We know why you’re here.” In a long rant about Taylor Swift, he claimed she “doesn’t mean it” if she doesn’t take her husband’s last name.
Can you see how comments like these are why many people see him as a misogynist?
Standing at a pulpit in a church, Kirk loudly said of controversial trans swimmer, Lia Thomas, “You hear that, William Thomas? You’re an abomination to God!” to cheers from the audience.
My Christian brothers and sisters, I ask you, are these the actions of a man who sees other human beings—all of them—as image-bearers? As people like himself whom Christ died to save? Even if you agree and believe he’s simply interpreting Scripture in good faith, can you see how words like these strike others as deeply offensive and hateful?
Speaking about Democrats, Kirk said, “Like, we’re dealing with maggots, vermin, and swine here.” He said, “They’re parasites. The left are cockroaches.”
My friends on the right, can you understand why people whose algorithms have been showing them this side of Charlie Kirk are skeptical of the flowery descriptions of him as a thoughtful, cross-aisle engager?
A man was killed on camera. In broad daylight, with scores of witnesses. The video of his murder was everywhere. No one’s family should have to see that. It shocks the consciences of all decent people that anyone could see such a crime and then go use their online platform to say of the murdered man, “He’s a scumbag.” “He shouldn’t be celebrated.” Surely, we can all agree on that?
Can we still agree if I tell you I’m not talking about Charlie Kirk? I’m talking about George Floyd, and the direct quotes of Charlie Kirk about the murdered man—although Kirk never even accepted that Floyd was murdered, despite the conclusions of two separate autopsies and a jury of the murderer’s peers. On the last show he recorded, posted on the same day he died, Kirk addressed the left: “You guys…changed the entire fiber and action of the entire civilization all around a lie because George Floyd overdosed on the side of the street.”
A personal note: that shocked me. I gasped aloud when I heard it. Especially after the hours I’ve spent in the past days searching videos and tributes of Charlie Kirk and seeing the side of him his supporters have seen all these years. The kind man, the man who reached out. The good Christian. Contrasted with the callousness of those words, the harshness of his voice, the willful disregard for the truth…they don’t seem like the same man.
And so we’re left with these two Charlie Kirks. They both existed. We have the proof.
What do we do with this?
We can purpose to seek and to see the humanity in those with whom we disagree. For those of us who are believers in Christ, we can remind ourselves, over and over, that every single human being is an image-bearer, loved by God. While we may give bad, ignorant, and immoral ideas no mercy, we can try, always, to remember that the people who espouse them are people, just like us. Imperfect, complicated, and subject to all the weaknesses and biases common to humanity.
We can especially try to remain aware that our algorithm fundamentally shapes our understanding of reality, and there may be things we’re missing.
We can admire the good aspects of Charlie Kirk and emulate them. We can fairly judge the bad aspects and strive to overcome them in our own lives.
Most importantly, we can choose to see one another, even those with whom we vehemently disagree, as human beings, created equal, endowed by our Creator with an unalienable right to life. This fundamental American doctrine is the wide, firm foundation where we can all find common ground.






